Ulma forja lawsuit

It follows a jury verdict in September in favor of Boltex and Weldbend on all counts in a lawsuit by the American carbon steel flange manufacturers against Ulma for false advertising and unfair competition. According to Judge Hanen, Ulma did so in multiple ways: brochures and presentations they provided to actual and potential customers; email communications to actual and potential customers; responses to customer requests for quote; engravings markings on the flanges themselves; signed certificates of inspection, and Mill Test Reports.

Thus, most of their advertising was false. Iosu Bastida, sales director of Ulma USA, acknowledged in court that company communications and marketing materials stating that they did normalize their flanges were incorrect and that Ulma knew it was not normalizing flanges consistent with ATSM standards.

Engineers design refineries, pipelines, pressure vessels and other piping systems based on the product fully complying with the standard. It is not up to Ulma to determine what parts of the standards they comply with. About Weldbend Corporation Weldbend is the industry leader with over 60 years of performance- proven reputation.

Weldbend pioneered advance techniques and designed equipment uniquely capable of producing only the finest carbon steel weld flange and weld fitting products. Weldbend manufactures stock for large inventories and prompt and precise shipments. As a family business, Weldbend is committed to delivering a level of service and product that achieves complete customer satisfaction.

Further information about Weldbend can be found at www. About Boltex Manufacturing Company Inc. Boltex is a vertically-integrated manufacturer of quality, American-made forged steel flanges for the oil and gas, petrochemical, transmission, engineering and construction industries. Our products are sold exclusively through wholesale distributors. This integrated approach allows Boltex to manage our in-house forging, heat treatment, metallurgical testing and robotic machining processes and thereby ensure the delivery of only the highest quality domestic flanges.

The Boltex commitment to quality is matched only by our on-time delivery performance made possible by our extensive finished flange and rough forging inventories. Further information about Boltex can be found at www. Press release content from PR Newswire.

ulma forja lawsuit

The AP news staff was not involved in its creation. February 11, GMT. Connect with the definitive source for global and local news.

The Associated Press. All rights reserved.Boltex Manufacturing Company, L. Interested in this case? Sign up to receive real-time updates. Thumbnails Document Outline Attachments. Highlight all Match case. Toggle Sidebar. Zoom Out. More Information Less Information. Enter the password to open this PDF file:. Cancel OK. File name:. File size:. Title:. Author:. Subject:. Keywords:. Creation Date:. Modification Date:. Creator:. PDF Producer:. PDF Version:.

Page Count:. Preparing document for printing…. Full Text 6 Case No. Perloff Marc B. Collier Texas Bar No. Texas Federal ID No. Bar No. Grant Robert L. Rouder Texas Bar No. Zarlenga S. Lindinger S. Washington, D. James for Testing Vicmar Servs. Montgomery Co.The Court found that Ulma, which provides flanges for use in American pipelines, refineries and chemical plants, "intended to deceive customers by mislabeling the flanges" and even did so afterwhen the original lawsuit was filed.

In ordering the permanent injunction, Judge Hanen stated that "an injunction would greatly benefit the public" and that "[m]islabeling the qualities and characteristics of a product like the flanges in question which are used throughout the petroleum industry, is a dangerous practice.

The ruling also ordered Ulma to "recall any product which purports to be normalized," which has not been normalized per ASTM international standards.

Plaintiffs sued Ulma inafter metallurgical testing showed that Ulma's flanges had not been normalized and were not in conformance with industry standards as claimed by Ulma's advertising. According to Judge Hanen, Ulma did so in multiple ways: brochures and presentations they provided to actual and potential customers; email communications to actual and potential customers; responses to customer requests for quote; engravings markings on the flanges themselves; signed certificates of inspection, and Mill Test Reports.

Thus, most of their advertising was false. Nerea VillarCFO of Ulma Forja, then admitted under oath that Ulma's decision to "not heat treat and properly normalize all the flanges sold as AN" had "always" been the process at Ulma "probably" dating back to Engineers design refineries, pipelines, pressure vessels and other piping systems based on the product fully complying with the standard.

It is not up to Ulma to determine what parts of the standards they comply with. Judge Hanen's order permanently enjoins Ulma from manufacturing, selling or otherwise distributing, directly or indirectly through distributors, any flange that is marked, engraved, advertised or labeled as complying with ATSM A and ATSM AN or as being normalized that does not comply with ASTM standards. About Weldbend Corporation Weldbend is the industry leader with over 60 years of performance- proven reputation.

Weldbend pioneered advance techniques and designed equipment uniquely capable of producing only the finest carbon steel weld flange and weld fitting products. From start to finish, Weldbend strives to be "The Standard" to which weld fittings and weld flanges are manufactured, stored, organized, and shipped.

Weldbend manufactures stock for large inventories and prompt and precise shipments. As a family business, Weldbend is committed to delivering a level of service and product that achieves complete customer satisfaction. About Boltex Manufacturing Company Inc.

Boltex is a vertically-integrated manufacturer of quality, American-made forged steel flanges for the oil and gas, petrochemical, transmission, engineering and construction industries.

Our products are sold exclusively through wholesale distributors. This integrated approach allows Boltex to manage our in-house forging, heat treatment, metallurgical testing and robotic machining processes and thereby ensure the delivery of only the highest quality domestic flanges.

The Boltex commitment to quality is matched only by our on-time delivery performance made possible by our extensive finished flange and rough forging inventories.

All Rights Reserved. Menu Search Law. Follow Us.Ulma Sold More than 3. The Court found that Ulma, which provides flanges for use in American pipelines, refineries and chemical plants, "intended to deceive customers by mislabeling the flanges" and even did so afterwhen the original lawsuit was filed.

In ordering the permanent injunction, Judge Hanen stated that "an injunction would greatly benefit the public" and that "[m]islabeling the qualities and characteristics of a product like the flanges in question which are used throughout the petroleum industry, is a dangerous practice. The ruling also ordered Ulma to "recall any product which purports to be normalized," which has not been normalized per ASTM international standards.

It follows a jury verdict in September in favor of Boltex and Weldbend on all counts in a lawsuit by the American carbon steel flange manufacturers against Ulma for false advertising and unfair competition. Boltex, based in Houstonand Weldbend, headquartered outside of Chicagobecame suspicious several years ago when Ulma began offering supposedly heat-treated "normalized" flanges to U.

Plaintiffs sued Ulma inafter metallurgical testing showed that Ulma's flanges had not been normalized and were not in conformance with industry standards as claimed by Ulma's advertising. According to Judge Hanen, Ulma did so in multiple ways: brochures and presentations they provided to actual and potential customers; email communications to actual and potential customers; responses to customer requests for quote; engravings markings on the flanges themselves; signed certificates of inspection, and Mill Test Reports.

Despite these claims, the court found that "during the relevant time period, at least 95 percent of the flanges Ulma advertised and sold into the United States which purported to be normalized and ASTM-compliant were not normalized in compliance with the ASTM standards. Thus, most of their advertising was false. Iosu Bastida, sales director of Ulma USAacknowledged in court that company communications and marketing materials stating that they did normalize their flanges were incorrect and that Ulma knew it was not normalizing flanges consistent with ATSM standards.

Nerea VillarCFO of Ulma Forja, then admitted under oath that Ulma's decision to "not heat treat and properly normalize all the flanges sold as AN" had "always" been the process at Ulma "probably" dating back to Engineers design refineries, pipelines, pressure vessels and other piping systems based on the product fully complying with the standard. It is not up to Ulma to determine what parts of the standards they comply with. Judge Hanen's order permanently enjoins Ulma from manufacturing, selling or otherwise distributing, directly or indirectly through distributors, any flange that is marked, engraved, advertised or labeled as complying with ATSM A and ATSM AN or as being normalized that does not comply with ASTM standards.

About Weldbend Corporation Weldbend is the industry leader with over 60 years of performance- proven reputation. Weldbend pioneered advance techniques and designed equipment uniquely capable of producing only the finest carbon steel weld flange and weld fitting products. From start to finish, Weldbend strives to be "The Standard" to which weld fittings and weld flanges are manufactured, stored, organized, and shipped.

Weldbend manufactures stock for large inventories and prompt and precise shipments. As a family business, Weldbend is committed to delivering a level of service and product that achieves complete customer satisfaction.

Further information about Weldbend can be found at www. About Boltex Manufacturing Company Inc. Boltex is a vertically-integrated manufacturer of quality, American-made forged steel flanges for the oil and gas, petrochemical, transmission, engineering and construction industries.

Our products are sold exclusively through wholesale distributors. This integrated approach allows Boltex to manage our in-house forging, heat treatment, metallurgical testing and robotic machining processes and thereby ensure the delivery of only the highest quality domestic flanges.

The Boltex commitment to quality is matched only by our on-time delivery performance made possible by our extensive finished flange and rough forging inventories. Further information about Boltex can be found at www. Sign in Mail Sign in to view your mail. Finance Home. PR Newswire February 10, Story continues.Weldbend Corp.

Department of Commerce in antidumping duty investigations concerning finished carbon steel flanges from India, Italy and Spain. This action follows the antidumping petitions filed by Weldbend and Boltex on June 30,with Commerce and the U. International Trade Commission seeking the enforcement and compliance of Indian, Italian and Spanish manufacturers with U. Coulas Jr. With respect to the antidumping investigation involving Spanish respondent Ulma Forja, S. Coop, it is being assigned the punishing dumping rate of All other Spanish producers are assigned the rate of These rates are expected to remain the same in the final dumping margin determination scheduled for AprilWeldbend and Boltex noted.

All other Italian producers are assigned the rate of Finally, Norma India Limited and R. All other Indian producers are assigned the rate of In Novemberboth of these Indian producers were also found preliminarily to have received illegal government subsidies, resulting in countervailing duty margins of 2. The additional duties that will be imposed on Indian imports will be the sum of the antidumping duties and the countervailing duties.

Once these preliminary rates are published in the Federal Register in about 5 days timeU. Weldbend and Boltex said they will continue to remain actively engaged in these investigations as they proceed to final determinations. The companies noted Commerce has outstanding information requests pending with some of these producers and has yet to conduct its on-site verifications at each of their locations.

Finished carbon steel flanges are forged rings of steel designed to join two sections of a piping system or to start a piping system from a pressure vessel, valve, or any other flange assembly.

I want to hear from you. Tell me how we can improve. This website requires certain cookies to work and uses other cookies to help you have the best experience. By visiting this website, certain cookies have already been set, which you may delete and block. By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to the use of cookies.

Visit our updated privacy and cookie policy to learn more. This Website Uses Cookies By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to our cookie policy.

Weldbend, Boltex Win False-Claims Lawsuit Against Ulma Forja

Learn More This website requires certain cookies to work and uses other cookies to help you have the best experience. January 31, Related Articles U.

DOC makes affirmative preliminary antidumping determinations DOC scheduled to make anti-dumping preliminary determination Jan. Related Products Lessons Learned in a Boiler Room: A common sense approach to servicing and installing commercial boilers. Related Directories Weldbend Corp.

ulma forja lawsuit

Industrial Valco J-K Enterprises. Report Abusive Comment. Supply House Times.Judge Andrew S. The Court found that Ulma, which provides flanges for use in American pipelines, refineries and chemical plants, "intended to deceive customers by mislabeling the flanges" and even did so afterwhen the original lawsuit was filed.

In ordering the permanent injunction, Judge Hanen stated that "an injunction would greatly benefit the public" and that "[m]islabeling the qualities and characteristics of a product like the flanges in question which are used throughout the petroleum industry, is a dangerous practice. The ruling also ordered Ulma to "recall any product which purports to be normalized," which has not been normalized per ASTM international standards.

Plaintiffs sued Ulma inafter metallurgical testing showed that Ulma's flanges had not been normalized and were not in conformance with industry standards as claimed by Ulma's advertising. According to Judge Hanen, Ulma did so in multiple ways: brochures and presentations they provided to actual and potential customers; email communications to actual and potential customers; responses to customer requests for quote; engravings markings on the flanges themselves; signed certificates of inspection, and Mill Test Reports.

Thus, most of their advertising was false. Nerea Villar, CFO of Ulma Forja, then admitted under oath that Ulma's decision to "not heat treat and properly normalize all the flanges sold as AN" had "always" been the process at Ulma "probably" dating back to Engineers design refineries, pipelines, pressure vessels and other piping systems based on the product fully complying with the standard.

It is not up to Ulma to determine what parts of the standards they comply with. Judge Hanen's order permanently enjoins Ulma from manufacturing, selling or otherwise distributing, directly or indirectly through distributors, any flange that is marked, engraved, advertised or labeled as complying with ATSM A and ATSM AN or as being normalized that does not comply with ASTM standards.

I want to hear from you. Tell me how we can improve. This website requires certain cookies to work and uses other cookies to help you have the best experience. By visiting this website, certain cookies have already been set, which you may delete and block. By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to the use of cookies. Visit our updated privacy and cookie policy to learn more. This Website Uses Cookies By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to our cookie policy.

Learn More This website requires certain cookies to work and uses other cookies to help you have the best experience. February 12, Related Articles Boltex and Weldbend urge U. Report Abusive Comment. Supply House Times.The Court found that Ulma, which provides flanges for use in American pipelines, refineries and chemical plants, "intended to deceive customers by mislabeling the flanges" and even did so afterwhen the original lawsuit was filed.

Federal Judge Orders Recall of Non-Standardized Pipeline Flanges

In ordering the permanent injunction, Judge Hanen stated that "an injunction would greatly benefit the public" and that "[m]islabeling the qualities and characteristics of a product like the flanges in question which are used throughout the petroleum industry, is a dangerous practice. The ruling also ordered Ulma to "recall any product which purports to be normalized," which has not been normalized per ASTM international standards.

It follows a jury verdict in September in favor of Boltex and Weldbend on all counts in a lawsuit by the American carbon steel flange manufacturers against Ulma for false advertising and unfair competition. Boltex, based in Houston, and Weldbend, headquartered outside of Chicago, became suspicious several years ago when Ulma began offering supposedly heat-treated "normalized" flanges to U.

Plaintiffs sued Ulma inafter metallurgical testing showed that Ulma's flanges had not been normalized and were not in conformance with industry standards as claimed by Ulma's advertising. According to Judge Hanen, Ulma did so in multiple ways: brochures and presentations they provided to actual and potential customers, email communications to actual and potential customers, responses to customer requests for quote, engravings markings on the flanges themselves, signed certificates of inspection, and Mill Test Reports.

Despite these claims, the court found that "during the relevant time period, at least 95 percent of the flanges Ulma advertised and sold into the United States which purported to be normalized and ASTM-compliant were not normalized in compliance with the ASTM standards. Thus, most of their advertising was false.

ulma forja lawsuit

Iosu Bastida, sales director of Ulma USA, acknowledged in court that company communications and marketing materials stating that they did normalize their flanges were incorrect and that Ulma knew it was not normalizing flanges consistent with ATSM standards.

Nerea Villar, CFO of Ulma Forja, then admitted under oath that Ulma's decision to "not heat treat and properly normalize all the flanges sold as AN" had "always" been the process at Ulma "probably" dating back to Engineers design refineries, pipelines, pressure vessels and other piping systems based on the product fully complying with the standard. It is not up to Ulma to determine what parts of the standards they comply with. Judge Hanen's order permanently enjoins Ulma from manufacturing, selling or otherwise distributing, directly or indirectly through distributors, any flange that is marked, engraved, advertised or labeled as complying with ATSM A and ATSM AN or as being normalized that does not comply with ASTM standards.

Login Free Trial Subscribe Advertise. Search Home Magazine MarchVol. Add Comment. Related News U. Connect with PGJ. All material subject to strictly enforced copyright laws.


Replies to “Ulma forja lawsuit”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *